Primer

What Is Islamic Philosophy?

Not a bridge between Greece and Europe, but a tradition of its own

For six centuries the most advanced philosophical work in the world was done in Arabic and Persian. Calling it a transmission belt is the most common way to get it wrong.

8 min

There is a version of the story in which Greek thought passes through the Islamic world on its way to medieval Europe, arriving usefully translated and otherwise unchanged. It is a tidy story and it is false. The philosophers in question were not couriers. They were arguing, and what they argued about shaped what Europe eventually received.

The work begins in ninth-century Baghdad, where a sustained translation effort brought Greek scientific and philosophical texts into Arabic, often through Syriac. Al-Kindi was the first to write philosophy in Arabic in his own voice. Al-Farabi, a generation later, built a political philosophy around what a virtuous city would require, and thought hard about how a philosopher and a prophet could both be telling the truth.

Ibn Sina and the systematic peak

Ibn Sina, known in Latin as Avicenna, produced the most complete philosophical system of the medieval world and a medical encyclopedia that was still being taught in Europe six hundred years later. His distinction between essence and existence, and his argument that a necessary being must underlie a world of merely possible ones, became standard equipment for later philosophers of several religions. He also posed a thought experiment about a person suspended in the void, deprived of every sensation, who would still know that they were: a question about self-awareness that arrived six centuries before Descartes sat down by his fire.

The argument that defined the tradition

Al-Ghazali, a jurist and mystic who had reached the top of the scholarly establishment, walked away from it in a crisis of certainty and later wrote a detailed critique of the philosophers, attacking their claims about causation and the eternity of the world. Ibn Rushd, known as Averroes, answered him point by point from the far west of the Islamic world. The exchange is one of the most serious arguments about reason and revelation anyone has had, and it is usually summarised badly as the moment Islamic philosophy stopped. It did not stop.

Beyond the falsafa

Ibn Arabi built a metaphysics of divine unity that shaped mystical thought from Anatolia to Sumatra. Ibn Tufayl wrote a philosophical novel about a child raised alone on an island who reasons his way to the truth without a teacher, which reached Europe and was read closely there. Ibn Khaldun, writing in the fourteenth century, analysed how societies cohere and decay in terms that historians and sociologists still find startling. None of these fits the description of a footnote.

Volume IV of the atlas follows this world from Baghdad to Córdoba, Bukhara, Cairo and Konya, with each thinker placed where they actually worked. The geography is not decoration here: the distances these arguments travelled, and the libraries they passed through, are much of the story.

Further reading

Continue reading